Appropriate supplier can lead the company to reach its competitive advantage. Many
researchers have been conducting research in supplier selection problem using various
multi-criteria decision making methods, including the Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) and its variation, such as Fuzzy AHP (FAHP). The research in this paper is trying to apply both AHP and FAHP in a glove manufacturer in order to see the role of the expert to the result of both methods. Four experts who are the staff in that company that have been working for 12-16 years are involved to see if FAHP is still needed. The FAHP method in this paper is based on the FAHP model developed by Chang (1996).